Posted on Google![]()
Patrick QuinnTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I'm incredibly thankful to Lauren Jacobson for taking the time to speak with me twice, during two big moments in my career. The first call came after an unexpected layoff, when I needed help strategizing next steps. The second was about a last-minute change to a new job offer, and I wasn't sure how to approach it. Lauren was extremely generous with her time and thoughtful in her replies, offering guidance and perspective during both conversations, entirely pro bono. While I can’t speak to her legal services beyond those calls, I deeply appreciated her willingness to help, her calm demeanor, and the clarity she offered at a pivotal moment in my career. Thank you again, Lauren!Posted on Google![]()
Evelyn GonzalezTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Im so thankful for Joseph C. Maya exceptional legal service. He help us with family matter and he was so professional and empathy. In the future I will be using his services.Posted on Google![]()
Jay PaigeTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I submitted a request and received a call within 30 minutes on a saturday evening. Joe took the time to hear details of my situation and provided me with very thoughtful guidance. I appreciate the time you took to speak with me!Posted on Google![]()
Bryce HumphreyTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Lauren Jacobson with Maya Murphy has been excellent to work with! She's been very generous with her time, and her experience and expertise in employment-related matters has been invaluable to our business. We won't hesitate to continue working with Lauren in the future when have similar employment needs.
Contact us today to discuss the details of your case with a free in-person or Zoom consultation.


Musto v. OptiCare Eye Health Centers, 2000 Conn. Super. LEXIS 2298
Employment Background
Dr. Anthony Musto owned an eye care services professional corporation with two other doctors from 1973 to 1996. He worked as a private practice ophthalmologist in the greater Bridgeport area until the three doctors sold the practice to OptiCare Eye Health Centers, Inc. on July 31, 1996. Dr. Musto owned one-third of the shares of the business, sold them to OptiCare for a profit of $590,000, and signed an employment agreement with OptiCare to work as an ophthalmologist on their payroll.
He worked as an OptiCare employee from August 1, 1996, to August 4, 2000, providing management with a one-year written notice of voluntary termination on August 1, 1999. Following his termination, Dr. Musto proceeded to open a private practice office in Fairfield and perform surgeries at Bridgeport Hospital, including three extremely rare procedures: dactocystorhinostomy, blethoroplasty, and removal of eyelid tumors.
The Non-Compete Agreement
Dr. Musto signed a non-compete agreement with OptiCare as part of his employment contract and initialed each page to demonstrate he understood the agreement’s obligations and restrictions. The restrictive covenant stipulated that Dr. Musto be prohibited from engaging in the practice of ophthalmology or ophthalmic surgery for a period of eighteen months following termination with fifteen miles of OptiCare’s Stratford or Bridgeport offices.
OptiCare sued to prevent further violations of the non-compete agreement because of Dr. Musto’s new practice in Fairfield, a location clearly within fifteen miles of the identified OptiCare offices. The company sought to enjoin him from performing general ophthalmic surgeries at Bridgeport Hospital, also located within the geographical restrictions, but did not ask the court to prevent him from performing the three rare surgeries since he was the only doctor on staff at the hospital with the requisite expertise and knowledge to perform them. Dr. Musto however argued before the court that the restrictions contained in the agreement were unreasonable and the court should deny OptiCare’s request for their enforcement.
The Court’s Decision
The court held that the non-compete agreement was in fact reasonable and granted OptiCare’s request for its enforcement. The court granted the request, stating, “Where the context of the covenant not to compete is the sale of the good will of an established business, the courts recognize that enforcement of the covenant is necessary to prevent the seller from depriving the buyer of the value of the transaction”. When OptiCare acquired Dr. Musto’s professional corporation, it purchased the asset of continued patronage from people who had been patients of that practice, and the court concluded that OptiCare was entitled to protection of this valuable asset.
When determining whether a restrictive covenant is reasonable, the court must determine if it affords more than fair and just protection to the party in whose favor it operates without unduly interfering with public interest. The eighteen-month duration was deemed reasonable because it was short enough not to cause any unwarranted or extreme hardships on Dr. Musto’s ability to start another practice. Additionally the court concluded that the fifteen-mile restriction was reasonable because it was not a distance greater than what was necessary to protect the good will asset that OptiCare acquired from Mr. Musto and his partners.
–
If you have any questions relating to your non-compete agreement or would like to discuss any element of your employment agreement, please contact Joseph C. Maya, Esq. by phone at (203) 221-3100 or via e-mail at JMaya@Mayalaw.com.
Related Posts
How Is Property Divided in a Connecticut Divorce?
Inspecting Personal Devices of School Staff
Conducting FBAs and Implementing BIPs