
ESSA: The Primary Law Governing American Public Education
The Every Student Succeeds Act (ESSA) is the current reauthorization of the Elementary and Secondary Education Act (ESEA), the foundational federal law for K-12 public education in the United States. ESSA was signed into law on December 10, 2015, and took effect during the 2017-18 academic year. It replaced and substantially revised the No Child Left Behind Act of 2001 (NCLB).
For Connecticut families, ESSA is the framework that governs how public schools are held accountable for student outcomes, how academic standards are set and assessed, how teachers are certified and evaluated, and what happens when schools are identified as low-performing. Understanding ESSA helps parents understand what their school district is required to do and what levers exist to push for improvement.
ESSA vs. No Child Left Behind: What Changed
The most fundamental shift from NCLB to ESSA was the transfer of accountability authority from the federal government to states and local districts. Under NCLB, the federal government established specific proficiency targets and penalized states — including withholding federal funding — when insufficient numbers of students reached those benchmarks. This created perverse incentives and a culture of teaching to the test.
| No Child Left Behind (2001) | Every Student Succeeds Act (2015) | |
|---|---|---|
| Accountability authority | Federal — rigid proficiency targets set in Washington | State-driven — states design their own accountability systems within federal guardrails |
| School penalties | Mandatory federal sanctions for schools missing targets, including restructuring and state takeover | States determine interventions; federal government cannot mandate specific school improvement strategies |
| Testing culture | Created culture of excessive standardized testing; high-stakes consequences drove curriculum narrowing | Maintained testing requirements but eliminated punitive federal accountability tied to specific cutoffs |
| Teacher quality | Required “highly qualified teacher” designation with specific federal definition | Eliminated “highly qualified” label; states set their own teacher quality standards |
| Local flexibility | Minimal — top-down federal requirements | Substantial — states and districts have significant discretion in implementation |
What ESSA Still Requires
Despite its increased flexibility, ESSA retains important federal requirements that apply in Connecticut:
Annual academic assessments
States must administer annual standardized assessments in:
- Reading and mathematics in grades 3 through 8 and once in high school
- Science at least once in grades 3-5, 6-9, and 10-12
Results must be reported publicly and disaggregated by student subgroups including race, ethnicity, income level, disability status, English learner status, and others.
Academic standards
States must maintain academic standards aligned with college and career readiness. ESSA does not require adoption of any specific standards (eliminating the Common Core controversy of the NCLB era), but states must demonstrate their standards are rigorous.
School accountability and improvement
Each state must develop an accountability system that identifies schools as needing support in two main categories:
- Comprehensive support and improvement (CSI): The lowest-performing schools — typically the bottom 5% statewide — and high schools with graduation rates below 67%
- Targeted support and improvement (TSI): Schools where specific student subgroups are consistently underperforming
Schools identified for support must develop improvement plans, and states must take action if schools do not show progress over time. Connecticut develops its accountability plan and submits it to the U.S. Department of Education for approval.
Reporting and transparency
Schools must publish annual report cards with data on student achievement, graduation rates, teacher qualifications, per-pupil expenditure, and other metrics — disaggregated by student subgroup so that the performance of specific groups, including students with disabilities, is visible.
ESSA and Students with Disabilities
ESSA applies to all students in public schools receiving federal Title I funding, including students with disabilities. Key provisions affecting students with disabilities include:
- Accountability inclusion: Students with disabilities must be included in accountability systems. Their performance cannot be averaged away into the general school data — it must be reported separately
- Assessment participation: Students with disabilities must participate in state assessments, with appropriate accommodations as specified in their IEP or 504 plan. Only a small percentage of students with the most significant cognitive disabilities may take alternate assessments
- Subgroup reporting: Schools where students with disabilities as a subgroup are consistently underperforming must be identified for targeted support and improvement
It is important to understand that ESSA operates alongside IDEA — it does not replace or modify a student’s rights under IDEA. A student’s IEP rights, FAPE guarantee, and procedural protections under IDEA are unchanged by ESSA. ESSA is primarily a school accountability framework; IDEA is the specific law governing special education services.
ESSA in Connecticut
Connecticut implements ESSA through its state education plan, submitted to and approved by the U.S. Department of Education. Connecticut’s plan establishes the state’s approach to academic standards, assessments, school accountability, and educator quality within the ESSA framework.
Connecticut uses the Smarter Balanced Assessment Consortium (SBAC) assessments in English language arts and mathematics, along with the Next Generation Science Standards (NGSS) assessments for science. These assessments satisfy ESSA’s annual testing requirements.
Schools identified as needing comprehensive or targeted support in Connecticut must work with the state and their district to develop and implement improvement plans. Connecticut has more flexibility under ESSA than it did under NCLB to tailor these interventions to local contexts.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does ESSA affect my child’s IEP or special education rights?
No. ESSA is a school accountability law — it governs how schools and states are held accountable for student outcomes. It does not modify the rights IDEA provides to students with disabilities. Your child’s IEP, FAPE guarantee, procedural safeguards, and right to an appropriate placement are all governed by IDEA and are unaffected by ESSA.
Can my child opt out of ESSA-required testing?
ESSA requires that at least 95% of students participate in state assessments. States must have policies addressing opt-outs and must factor participation rates into their accountability systems. Connecticut has its own opt-out policy. While parents in Connecticut can technically opt their child out, schools that fall below the 95% participation threshold may face accountability consequences. Consult with your district for the current policy.
What happens if my child’s school is identified as low-performing under ESSA?
A school identified for comprehensive support must develop an improvement plan and implement evidence-based interventions. If a school does not improve within a state-defined timeline, additional action is required. Parents of students in identified schools have rights to information about the school’s status and improvement plan. Under Title I, parents may also have the right to transfer their child to a higher-performing school within the district, subject to availability.
How is ESSA different from IDEA for students with disabilities?
ESSA and IDEA serve different purposes. ESSA is the general K-12 education law governing school accountability, standards, testing, and improvement. IDEA is the specific special education law that governs the rights of students with disabilities to a free appropriate public education, IEPs, procedural safeguards, and related services. Both laws apply simultaneously to students with disabilities — ESSA ensures they are counted in accountability systems, while IDEA governs the actual services they receive.




