A Georgia woman has filed a $5 million wrongful pregnancy lawsuit against Qualitest Pharmaceuticals. She claims she became pregnant despite taking her birth control pills in the packaging sequence. Of course, Qualitest has recalled a number of brands and lots of the pills because they were packaged in the incorrect sequence for effective contraception.
The woman’s asking for damages for pain and suffering, mental anguish, loss of capacity for the enjoyment of life, health care and treatment, loss of earnings, and a loss of ability to earn money.
The lawsuit seeks class-action status for all women who’ve become pregnant because of this product defect.
Qualitest Pharmaceuticals recalled several brands of oral contraceptives because they posed a risk of unplanned pregnancy. The drug itself is not defective, but a packaging mistake could lead to a woman taking the pills out of sequence. In that case, contraception would be ineffective, and a woman could become pregnant unintentionally.
Not All States Permit Claims for Wrongful Birth or Pregnancy
A packaging error can make a product defective. For example, the failure to warn of harmful side effects or to instruct in the safe or proper use of the product can serve as grounds for a lawsuit if a consumer is harmed by the failure. The mistake might also be a breach of warranty. So if an unplanned pregnancy can be considered “harm” a consumer could sue for this result.
About half the states permit lawsuits for what’s known as “wrongful birth.” It’s a controversial concept. The idea is that had the parents of a child known it would be born with a serious birth defect or condition, they would have terminated the pregnancy. Similarly, parents, if informed that a pregnancy carried the risk of defect, like a genetic disease, may have avoided conceiving altogether.
For example, a jury recently awarded the parents of a child born with no arms and one leg $4.5 million. The award is to compensate them for the expenses of caring for their child over his lifetime. The parents sued the ob/gyn who failed to observe the deformities in two sonograms. They also settled separate claims against a hospital whose technicians likewise failed to detect the abnormalities.
In the United States, unplanned pregnancies are as much the rule as the exception. According to the Centers for Disease Control, as many as half of US pregnancies are unplanned. Could someone besides the parents be legally liable for the consequences of an unintended pregnancy?
Sure enough, some states allow lawsuits for a “wrongful” pregnancy that results in a normal birth. The “wrongful” part can be a defective sterilization, like vasectomy or tubal ligation, or defective contraception. Damages are limited, however. They include the pain and suffering of pregnancy and labor, the costs of medical care for the same, and the costs of the failed procedure or contraceptive device. They exclude the costs of rearing a child.
This brings us back to the Qualitest recall. If a woman became pregnant as a result of the ineffectiveness of an oral contraceptive, she might have a cause of action for wrongful pregnancy. I asked attorney Tom Lamb, who authors the Drug Injury Watch blog, about it.
Lamb has been involved in numerous product liability cases involving adverse side effects from oral contraception. “Wrongful pregnancy, like wrongful birth, is a state-by-state matter,” he said. “So the first issue is, does the state permit these types of claims.”
Being allowed to sue and actually having a case are two different things, Lamb continues. “You’re likely to have several problems of proof. In the first place, all contraceptives carry some risk of pregnancy. They’re not 100 percent effective. Then there are likely to be questions about whether the contraceptives were used correctly.”
Lamb also notes that a Supreme Court decision from last June has seriously affected suits against generic drug makers. “The Mensing decision put a roadblock in front of failure to warn cases against generic drugmakers. So now whether you have any case at all may come down to whether your doctor prescribed you the ‘name brand’ or generic version of the drug that harmed you.”
That’s something even Justice Thomas, who wrote the opinion in the case, called unfair. Most people, including Lamb, agree. “Hopefully,” he said, “Congress will realize this and find the time to fix the law.”
By: Art Buono
At Maya Murphy, P.C., our experienced team of personal injury attorneys is dedicated to achieving the best results for individuals and their families and loved ones whose daily lives have been disrupted by injury. Our personal injury attorneys assist clients in New York, Bridgeport, Darien, Fairfield, Greenwich, New Canaan, Norwalk, Stamford, Westport, and throughout Fairfield County. If you have any questions relating to a products liability claim, bad drug or medical error claim, or personal injury claim or would like to schedule a free consultation, please contact our Westport office by phone at (203) 221-3100 or via e-mail at JMaya@Mayalaw.com
Keywords: oral contraceptives, wrongful pregnancy, wrongful pregnancy lawsuit, Qualitest Pharmaceuticals, unintended pregnancy, wrongful birth, wrongful birth lawsuit, bad drug, recalled drug, drug recall, Injury, personal injury, claim, personal injury claim, personal injury claims, personal injury claim attorney, injury attorneys, personal injury attorney, personal injury attorneys, injury attorney, personal injury lawsuit, personal injury lawyer, personal injury lawyers, injury lawyer, accident injury attorney, personal injury law firm, law firm, personal injury law, legal advice, legal office, Maya Murphy, www.Mayalaw.com, New York personal injury attorney, Connecticut personal injury attorney, Connecticut injury attorney, Westport personal injury attorney, Fairfield personal injury attorney, Fairfield personal injury lawyer, Westport personal injury lawyer, personal injury attorney in, tort lawyer, tort attorney, tort lawyer Fairfield county, find an attorney, how to find an attorney, work injury attorney, injury settlement, personal injury settlement, personal injury settlements, tort settlements, lawyers, lawyer, attorney, attorneys, attorneys in ct, New York, New York City, Bridgeport, Darien, Fairfield, Greenwich, New Canaan, Norwalk, Stamford, Westport, Weston, Fairfield County, mesothelioma, mesothelioma lawyer, asbestos, asbestos lawyer, lung cancer, lung cancer attorney, accident lawsuit, accident lawyers, accident attorney, accident injury lawyer, airplane crash attorney, Airplane injury lawyer, amputation lawyer, arm amputation lawyer, Auto Accident Death, auto accident injury attorney, accident injury attorney, auto accident injury lawyer, auto accident injury lawyers, auto accident settlement, car accident settlement attorney, auto crash attorney, auto crash lawyer, auto crash lawyers, auto injury lawyer, auto wreck attorney, automobile accident death, automobile accident lawyer, automobile accident lawyers, aviation attorney, aviation lawyer, back injury lawyer, best car accident lawyer, best car accident lawyers, bicycle accident lawyer, big rig accident lawyer, big rig truck accident, boat accident lawyer, boat accidents, brain injury lawyers, brain damage lawsuit, brain damage lawyer, brain damage lawyers, car accident, car accident claim, car accident death, car accident help, car accident injury lawyer, car accident injury lawyers, car accidents lawyer, car collision lawyer, car collision lawyers, car crash death, Car Crash Injury, car crash injury lawyer, car crash lawyer, car crash lawyers, car wreck lawyer, car wreck lawyers, child birth death, compensatory damages, construction accident lawyer, construction accidents lawyer, death by car accident, death by motorcycle accident, dog bite lawyer, animal bite attorney, defective products lawyer, product liability attorney, products liability lawyer, elder abuse attorney, elder abuse lawyer, fatal auto accident, fatal car accident, fatal car accident lawyer, fatal forklift accident, fatal injury lawyer, fatal truck accident, head injury lawyer, helicopter crash lawyer, highway accident lawyer, highway accidents, jury award, jury verdict, medical malpractice attorneys, hospital injury, hospital incompetence, hospital negligence, medical malpractice lawyers, malpractice attorney, hospital injury attorney, medical malpractice lawsuit, medical error, medical malpractice case, medical injury lawyer, medical injury attorney, motor vehicle accident, motor vehicle accident lawyer, motor vehicle accident attorneys, negligence lawyer, negligent injury attorney, lawyer for car accident, lawyers for car accident, pedestrian injuries, personal injury help, Personal Injury Law, premise liability attorney, premise liability lawyer, plane crash lawyer, punitive damages, rig truck accident lawyer, renter attorney, landlord attorney, road traffic accidents, rollover accident, RV accident, RV injury lawyer, slip and fall, slip and fall lawyer, slip and fall attorneys, school bus accident, serious car injury lawyer, truck accident, truck crash lawyer, truck wreck lawyer, trucking accident lawyer, trucking accident lawyers, trucking accidents lawyer, vehicle rollover, whiplash neck injuries, whiplash settlement, Wrongful Death attorney, Wrongful Death attorneys, Wrongful Death Claim, wrongful death complaint